Facebook Pixel

Customer Review

Average customer rating
4.9
Out of 5
Rating breakdown
5
(21537)
4
(724)
3
(69)
2
(11)
1
(21)
Overall rating
Customer Average

100% of customers that buy from Molly's Custom Silver give 4 or 5-Star rating.


February 06, 2026 by Eliza Benner
 
The buckles came out beautiful!

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Alia Palosaari
 
Customer service was great and they were very timely! I love the variety of high quality buckles at reasonable price points. Will be ordering from Molly’s again!

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Michaela Sparry
 
My belt buckle was made very well! And thought out the entire process of making it I was getting updates knowing at what stage it was on. And when it arrived it was exactly what I wanted. And very well crafted.

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Jeff Macres
 
Excellent craftsmanship! I ordered a belt buckle for my son and it was way beyond my expectations!

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Stacie Smithee
 
Buckles are beautifully and arrived in 8 weeks!

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Carie Wise
 
Mollys was able to change the gem layout in the buckle that we ordered for my daughter's senior year. They were very prompt and courteous when we were talking with customer support. If we emailed to check the status they responded promptly. I would absolutely recommend working with Molly's Custom Silver. We will be returning customers.

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Ashley Rolen
 
Its a beautiful custome piece! The only issue we had, was the black stuff they used to polish or glue (im not sure what it is), was all over the side of the buckle, even on part of the front. HOWEVER, it wasn't a big issue, as my husband was able to scrape most off and use a soft polisher and polish it off. I would recommend this company as the work itself is beautiful! I just think a little more time needs to be put into the quality check!

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Grant Johnson
 
the order came with the specs that that I requested. It is truly a costom belt buckle!

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Paige Samples
 
Molly’s has excellent customer service and their product are such high quality

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Diane Kamps
 
Love your product, always top notch, and wonderful awards and you stay up with western trends that people like.

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Wendy Grana
 
I am extremely happy with the quality of the buckle, besides great workmanship.

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Harley Ritter
 
Amazing quality

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Anthony Uhl
 
The cow tag turned out great!

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Emma Foular
 
The buckle turned out just how I wanted it to.

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Megan Davies
 
Excellent experience from start to finish! Custom work turned out exactly as expected. Mock-ups matched finished product perfectly.

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Dianna Porter
 
Mollys is SUPER easy to work with. The end product is ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL. I will always be a repeat customer

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by REAGAN STICE
 
Mollys custom silver delivers beautiful products in a timely manner. We have ordered several belt buckles and dog tags from them and have been overly impressed by each one.

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Kelly Burchell
 
When I had questions, she’d respond very quickly and was on top of my order. When I received my product it was better than we expected!

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Brian Kincheloe
 
Great quality every time. Takes a little too long to receive, but worth the quality.

 Verified Buyer


February 06, 2026 by Michelle Baranow
 
Excellent customer service!

 Verified Buyer