100% of customers that buy from Molly's Custom Silver give 4 or 5-Star rating.
July 25, 2026 by Aliviah McGuire
When you mixed my buckle up with someone else's you fixed it and gave me a free necklace (wich i appreciate very much). Your very high like everything was VERY high quality and try to make every part of the experience perfect. Tho the necklace i received did have a stone that wasnt even in its hole and neither were the stones on my buckle but that ended up being ok cause they came off very easy so I could glue them on the right way. Also I love the buckle yall did with Avery Anna. Over all I think I will order from you again in the future and I will be telling my friends about you and your high quality.
Verified Buyer
July 25, 2026 by Rick Landes
I sent my buckle back to have a few stones replaced and cleaned up after 3 years of wear and tear.
I was told it had a warranty that would take care of it.
They send me a label for mailing it back that included postage paid and in six weeks received my buckle back. At zero cost!!
The buckle looks amazing, as good as new. Thank you for being one of the good guys.
Verified Buyer
July 25, 2026 by Cody Hill
Well done work
Verified Buyer
July 25, 2026 by Garett Windholz
You guys have great buckles and customer service has been great. What I am most impressed about is every year I give away buckles and a couple times they have been not completely right but you guys get on it right away and fix it. We all make mistakes but your customer service doing right by your customers and getting it fixed is top notch and I appreciate that!!!
Verified Buyer
July 25, 2026 by Tracy Naves
Our inagural miniature donkey show...Molly's went above and beyond to ensure our order was processed expeditiously. The buckles are beautiful!!! Out West Long Ears thanks you so much!
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Kaitlin Corey
Beautiful buckle! It took awhile to receive it but it was totally worth it! I wear it everyday
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Elizabeth Stuart
My buckle is beautiful and very custom. I wound up getting a different belt but it's beautiful and decided to keep it!
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Stacie Pollard
Last 4-H season I ordered buckles from you and everything went great! You were able to help with a different archery symbol than the one you had posted on your website. The ordering process this year wasn't nearly as smooth. I made the order and then looked at the proofs when they were ready. They were completely wrong. One archery symbol was a beef. On one line it said "nothing". I sent it back for the changes and the next proofs still didn't have the archery symbol I wanted. Since I was pressed for time I approved the artwork. Unfortunately they were still received late and the kids didn't get them at the awards ceremony. They had to wait until the following week. I may try a new company next year.
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Erik Van Cleave
Had to send back my buckle to have it polished the correct way and the name is STILL of center after it just came back!!!
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Kinsley Audia
Loved it
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Maddy Gutchak
I’m not sure if this was just my order, but the hook on my buckle does not stay on my belt loop, due to the blocking piece.
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Kinsey Webb
This was my 2nd buckle iv purchased through mollys, and of course it exceeded my expectations, mollys always does a amazing job at communicating, timely delivery and especially at the fine craftsmanship that Mollys provides everybody, I’ll absolutely be ordering more buckles in the future
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Hector Herrera
I absolutely recommend to all my fellow friends yall do an amazing job. I really liked the way I sent yall the picture that I wanted in graved in my buckle it came out perfect just how I had it imagined in my head thank you !!
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Juli Jo Kelly
Every order I have placed has been shipped in a timely manner and also very nice quality. I appreciate having a place to buy award buckles at an affordable price.
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Donna Kremp
Sent an email and was not responded back to, then thought the buckle would have a copper background and yes I ok’d the buckle under the impression you got my email for exactly what the picture looked like on your website
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Jessica Banks
Beautiful buckle. Unfortunately it was too big for my daughter's liking. Shes going to use it as decoration and we have already ordered a smaller one. She did suggest maybe having each size modeled on a person for better perspective. But we are happy with the service and will recommend Molly's buckles in the future. ☺️
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Kory Flamand
Absolutely amazing, everything was spot on and already recommended friends
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Sarah Dudley
Absolutely in love with my buckle!!
Verified Buyer
July 24, 2026 by Cullen Theisen
I have ordered three buckles from Molly's Custom Silver , in the last few years. Thfinished product is not o ly very high quality , but also beautiful craftsmanship! My wife could not be more happy with her buckle , and has recieved numerous compliments on it. Thank you for your attention to detail , excellent communication, and all around fantastic products . I will order again and have and will co tinue to recommend Molly's Custom Silver!